Home Cinema Choice website
www.homecinemachoice.com


To enquire about advertising, click here.
Home News Blog Magazine Reviews Articles Awards Community Links Contact Us Email a friend
Slimline tonics February 2003 Group test

JOHN ARCHER TAKES DOWN HIS OLD ATHENA PRINTS TO MAKE WAY FOR FIVE BLISTERING NEW PLASMA SCREENS

Not so very long ago, the thought of having a TV you could hang on the wall like a painting occupied pigs-might-fly territory. But now plasma screens have made that dream a reality. Indeed, they seem to be everywhere you look these days. Except, very likely, in your own home.

There have traditionally been two main reasons for this lack of a domestic invasion. First, plasma screens have typically been bank-breakingly expensive. Second, not many of them have really been that good, at least not if judged against the now phenomenal standards of a good CRT or rear-projection TV.

All this is changing at breakneck speed, however. For a start, prices are plummeting. One model in this megatest weighs in with an RRP of just £2,500. And performance is improving exponentially too. By the end of this megatest, my bet is that you'll be seriously considering trading in your CRT TV ­ such is the allure of performance, PC compatibility and space-saving slimness.

In fact, all of these plasma TVs can be considered as the vanguard of plasma's full-on mainstream assault, declaring war on your wallet along the way. So if you don't want to surrender your cash to the wrong side, read on.

In this group test
HITACHI PLATARA CL32PD3000
SAMSUNG PS-42P2SB
SONY KZ-42TS1E
THOMSON WYSIUS 32WS95UF
TOSHIBA 35WP26
SAMSUNG PS-42P2SB Plasma television

£3000 (APPROX) 020 8391 0168 http://www.samsungelectronics.com

Samsung can be considered one of the most aggressive plasma players in the game, both in terms of pricing and the sheer number of screens it produces. But even by Samsung's heady standards the 42P2SB is an extraordinary unit. A 42in screen, with speakers, speaker stands, tuner box and screen desktop stand for as little as £3,000? Did Samsung have to twist the arm of its quality control department in order to get this one out there?

Description

It's not an immediately stylish or striking-looking screen, and, as such, lacks the initial impact of some other screens in this test. But the silvery frame is glossy and slender enough to grow on you over time. I liked the cute little speaker stands, too. And while the external AV box is a little chunky compared to the screen, it is no more so than most of its rivals.

Connections

The Samsung's media box carries a very healthy roster of sockets, distinguished in particular by phono audio line-outs, indicative of a Pro-Logic decoder; three Scarts of which two can handle RGB; a 15-pin PC input; a DVI input; and two sets of AV component video jacks. An excellent array.

Operation

The onscreen menus are functional, containing a few ambiguous icons, but fairly well structured overall. However, the remote control is a nightmare to use, thanks to a joystick-style menu navigator that's unbearably fiddly, inaccurate and uncomfortable.

Distinguishing features

This is the only plasma in this group test to offer an easy route to true surround sound, thanks to Pro-Logic decoding and all the line-outs and setup facilities necessary. There's a Virtual Dolby mode if you don't want surround sound speakers, plus a twin-tuner picture-in-picture system. We didn't find any obvious screenburn counter measures, though.

Picture

Picture quality is refined but not exactly dramatic. Samsung has taken a refreshingly naturalistic approach to image reproduction. However, it's not very contrasty. These days we're getting accustomed to panels that are capable of displaying true black, but the 42P2SB adds a greyish sheen over everything that makes deep blacks impossible. Resolution is also limited by the 'widescreen VGA' resolution of the panel.

With protracted viewing, though, its great strengths start to shine through. First, there's practically no banding or haloing around bright spots or over dark, shaded backgrounds. Panning cameras are handled well, too, with little in the way of side effects. And finally the picture is impressively devoid of noise, be it grain, grey pixelisation or crawling dots, even, happily, with tuner footage. A real grower.

Sound

As well as looking good on their neat little stands, this Samsung's speakers are impressively potent. They produce an exceptional amount of bass and depth for such skinny items, have the capacity and attack to expand during explosive movie moments, and manage to make dialogue rich and clear. They're not quite as astute with trebly detail, but we were still very impressed overall.

Conclusion

The PS-42P2SB is a bit of a strange brew. Its pictures are an odd mix of the cutting edge and conventional. But with a price tag of just £3,000, we reckon you might find yourself able to live with the weaknesses that bit easier!

LAB RESULTS

Colour: Practically no bleed; good, hard edges ­ excellent

Geometry: Perfect

Frequency response: Some detail visible at 5.8MHz ­ very good

FEATURES

Tuner/AV box: Yes/yes

Audio output: 2 x 10W

Scarts: Three (two RGB)

Standard component video inputs: Yes

Soundstage widener: Yes

Picture-in-picture: Yes

Resolution: 852 x 480

Anti-screenburn measures: Orbiter

Dimensions: 1,039(w) x 635(h) x 89(d)mm

Weight: 32kg

RATINGS

Highs: Clean picture; sound; price

Lows: Slightly unnatural image tone; remote joystick

Picture
Sound
Features
Overall

Grouptest conclusion

Things are heating up in the plasma world. We've seen a number of panels in this test hitting price points low enough to have some high-end CRT TVs quaking in their boots. And none of them are poor performers.

Propping up the four 'runners up' is Thomson's 32WS95UF. Thomson was an early supporter of plasma technology, but it seems to have been overtaken by its competitors. Maybe it wants to aim for value rather than ultimate quality. Certainly the price point is aggressive, but we know the brand has better things to come.

The next three screens are very difficult to separate. We've given fourth place to Toshiba. It may have an excellent design and contrast range compared to the Sony and Samsung units, but there were too many occasions when we were aware of the other problems of plasma technology. Third is Samsung, with its amazing price offset against a moderated performance and second-stream contrast. In second place is the Sony, which has managed to win us over with its gorgeous looks and home-oriented intentions.

The Sony comes in a whisper behind our winner: Hitachi's CL-32PD3000. This Hitachi delivers the lot, cutting edge picture performance, friendly operation and a fabulously affordable price. It puts everyone else in the position of playing catch-up.

In this group test
HITACHI PLATARA CL32PD3000
SAMSUNG PS-42P2SB
SONY KZ-42TS1E
THOMSON WYSIUS 32WS95UF
TOSHIBA 35WP26

Home Cinema Choice, February 2003

Hardware review archive

Search for:

made by:

 

were reviewed:

 

-- or --

Search for:

--------

sort results by:

12th May 2008

Direct TVs – cheap Plasma and LCD HD-Ready TVs

Reviews and more on Ciao Find the best home cinema system, DVD player or speakers for you.
Support this site and visit our sponsors.
Home News Blog Magazine Reviews Articles Awards Community Links Contact Us Top

Our suite of Home Cinema Magazines

Managed by
Developed and managed by M2N Limited, freelance website developers.  Click here for more information

Powered by
Site hosted by Global Gold

Future Publishing Limited
Click to visit the What Video and Widescreen TV website
Click to visit the Home Cinema Choice website
Click to visit the What Plasma & LCD TV website
© Future Publishing Limited. Reg No. 2008885 England. 30 Monmouth Street, Bath, BA1 2BW.